AVENUE Real Estate - Plymouth, Wisconsin

Greg R.

POOR COMMUNICATION. If you like to be in the loop as to what is going on, then go with someone else.
She convinced me to utilize her services because she had a "comprehensive marketing strategy". I asked how that was different from what others could offer, and was told it basically meant her connections and networking skills were superior to others.
Claimed she had 10 people lined up and ready to buy my house.....(2 of which were cash buyers, and 1 was her dad who sold his condo and needed a place to live).
Hot market and all the connections, yet she convinced me to go "full market" anyway to lure even more interest and potentially drive the price up. Cost me almost $4k extra so the OTHER agent from a different reality (who actually brought in a buyer) could get a cut.

No feedback from open house. Could not tell me approximately how many people showed up......or whether or not a sign in sheet was utilized.......and would not answer when I asked if she was physically present at the open house.
Actually had an offer on the house but I wasn't made aware of it until a day and a half later.......and was only told about the offer AFTER i asked.

If you enjoy stress, 11:45pm texts, (yes....all documented and saved) and no sense of urgency until the last minute, then go for it. If not, go with someone else.

Charles G.

More than happy to share another negative review of Katy Cain. Literally can’t believe people still use her services.
Katy LITERALLY broke into my condo for a showing. The potential buyers told me several months later. It was FSBO and I would’ve known if she wanted to show it.
Messaged her. Nothing back. Not surprised.
Here’s another tidbit. 3 properties in our building she listed had “clean” condition reports. Guess what? We have some major building to explain to the new buyers. Do not trust her. So many terrible reviews that frankly don’t surprise me.

Anna

This review is for Katy Cain specifically. I absolutely DO NOT recommend dealing with Katy at all. She does not communicate and does not follow proper protocols.

My boyfriend and I were extremely interested in a house for sale that was brokered by Katie. We looked at the house with our realtor on a Thursday, and put an offer in immediately. We signed the necessary paperwork and the realtor sent it to Katy. The seller had until 11:59 pm Friday to either accept or reject our offer. We kept in contact with our realtor all of Friday. She tried calling, texting, and emailing Katy throughout the day with no response. On Saturday we decided to speak to the seller directly. The seller did not receive our offer and was told by Katy she would receive all offers on Monday. We had to sign documents again for a new contract as the other one expired. Monday came around and same issues. Our realtor did not receive any response from Katy. Same deal on Tuesday. We had to speak to the seller again on Wednesday to find out what was going on.

Even the seller had poor communication from Katy. She did not show up when she was supposed to to take pictures of the inside of the house. The seller waited as long as she could, but had to leave for an appointment.

This process has been the worst experience I've ever had. Definitely will not even consider a house if Katy Cain is selling it.

Seranya A.

If I could give Donna Krueger from Avenue Real Estate 10 stars I would! She was with us every step of the way through a whirlwind tour of homes to the offer and closing. Donna was always honest, returned phone calls and communications promptly and kept us on track. She knows the communities and was able to direct us to other services we needed. Don't go it alone - buying or selling! Get a great agent like Donna, and Avenue Real Estate on your side.

Kara C.

We had a wonderful experience working with Jim selling our home! Extremely helpful and responsive. He took his time guiding us through the process and answering all questions we had. We could not be happier and would highly recommend.

Stephanie R.

Thumbs down to whoever gave Avenue the bad review because that is beyond false 👎 I would rate them ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

We want to send a BIG thank you to Jim Haucke at Avenue Real Estate 🥂 We are so thankful for your hard work & dedication! If anyone is looking for an exceptional realtor to find you a home, look NO FURTHER! We are beyond grateful for the home he found us and the exceptional service he delivered along this journey!

Adam

Shady actions that went against seller's and buyer's best interests. Also, just extremely poor communication needed to close.

Having all either five or one star reviews is a red flag.

Holly

Contractual agreements not honored. No longer a client and have asked that our listing be removed and after 3 days still listed on MLS and Avenue Real Estate. and their response was no response or action. If google would allow a sub par negative star review that is what I would have left.